By Kalyan S. Mukherjee ’27

Since the election of President Donald Trump in the United States, populism as a method to get elected to office has been vindicated throughout the Western world. On both sides of the Atlantic, populism has proliferated. A clear example of this is Vice President JD Vance’s speech at the Munich Security Conference, where he insinuated that Europe was failing to protect free speech by not allowing far-right groups with extremist ideologies to enjoy full free speech. He claimed they were failing in their ‘Democratic principles.’ Vance also met with AFD (Alternative for Deutschland) leader Alice Weidel, the far-right and Elon Musk-backed party in Germany whose members have made sympathetic remarks in regard to nazism. It is also important to note that Vance did not meet with Germany’s prospective chancellor Friedrich Mertz, apparently considering the fringe far-right leader more important. This incident is just one of many that shows how the success of populist politics through the MAGA movement in the U.S. has influenced Europe.
Though what Vance said at the time may have been shocking and garnered international headlines, it is not as serious as some of the more pernicious ways populist actors have influenced European countries. A striking example of how dangerous this populism can be was seen in Romania earlier this year, where their presidential election was annulled by the country’s Supreme Court because leading candidate Calin Georgescu’s campaign was found to have been heavily influenced by Russian money. This fiasco elicited a comment from Vice President Vance in his infamous Munich speech. He said: “If your democracy can be destroyed with a few hundred thousand dollars of digital advertising from a foreign country, then it wasn’t very strong to begin with.” This was an extremely inflammatory statement which the Romanian government vehemently denied (and proved wrong by managing to elect a president democratically.) The candidate who won, Nicisur Dan, represents the pro-Western side of Romanian politics. He beat hard right opponent George Simion, who is notably pro-Moscow and has a dubious past. Simion’s party, The Alliance for the Unity of Romanian (AUR), is considered very “Trumpian,” with much of its policy directed towards typical anti-establishment, anti-corruption, and anti-immigration populist policies. He is also an ultra-nationalist and vowed to bring back Georgescu, though he consistently claimed that he was protecting democracy (a common tactic used by populists.) He failed to get elected, and the Romanian government is now headed by an alliance between centrist and left-leaning parties against the AUR, which leads the opposition.
The situation in Romania is not perfect, and the new government is going to face a slew of challenges trying to cement its authority. However, they have been able to keep populist, pro-Moscow forces at bay for the time being. This is contrary to what is happening in the UK right now where their populist party, Reform, appears to be leading the traditional parties in polls. The next general election is still more than two years away, and it is possible that the current Labour government could gain support by then. But these numbers are still extremely concerning. During recent council elections in the UK, Reform took a lion’s share of the seats, showing that likely voters in local elections are increasingly turning towards populist candidates. However, Reform’s governance has been shambolic, as the fate of the Kent County councilors reveals.
How American politics has influenced this strong populist, hard-right tide in Europe is quite serious. Many populist leaders in Europe are pro-Russian and against providing aid to Ukraine. This can be seen most prominently in the Moldovan elections, where the party running against the pro-EU bloc is vehemently pro-Russian, showing the risk of letting the hard-right win. The AfD in Germany, mentioned earlier, favors a neutral approach in Ukraine, which would seriously hamper the war effort. This position is further vindicated by actions from the White House, such as the new National Security Strategy, the hostile Trump-Zelenskyy meeting earlier this year, and a cozying up to Russia within the late 2025 Ukraine negotiations.
The populist hard-right party in Poland, the Law and Justice Party, is perhaps the most dangerous group in Europe that could threaten American interests there, considering the importance of Poland in the eastern front of NATO. While current Polish president Karol Nawrocki has claimed that he would not remove support from Ukraine, he has also stated that he will not seek further integration within NATO and the EU in the face of Russian aggression.
These examples show that, despite what the current U.S. administration advertises, the rise of the hard right in Europe can only serve to harm American interests in the long run. This pro-Russian, far-right tide will lead to the further withdrawal of these countries from America’s sphere of influence and closer to Russia’s. This means that these nations will be more amenable to Russia and more likely to withdraw aid to Ukraine in a moment when aid is needed most.

