‘Gotcha Liberalism’ Fails: Why Christian Nationalists Don’t Care About Your Bible Verses

By Sophia Dotterweich ’27

Sophia Dotterweich ’27

Christian doctrine has long been used in order to justify certain political beliefs, acting as both a legitimator and sanctifier to political parties and ideologies throughout history. 

From the Divine Right of Kings in medieval Europe to the Manifest Destiny doctrine in the Antebellum South, Christian-backed rhetoric has always served religious and political aims. It’s clear that this rhetoric has become more blatant and powerful in recent years, especially since Trump’s second term began in January, with many on the political right invoking Christian values to justify policies that restrict LGBTQ+ rights, reproductive healthcare and immigration.

While the First Amendment protects religious freedom, it also establishes freedom from religion. Despite this, Christian nationalists fight to embed their religious beliefs into every aspect of American society. 

The Public Religion Research Institute reports that nearly 70% of Americans identify as Christian. It seems logical that most Americans, especially those who claim deep piety, would have some rudimentary knowledge of Christian teachings. Love, tolerance, charity and selfless devotion to Christ’s teachings and one’s neighbors appear frequently throughout the Gospel. 

Policies that prohibit personal liberties based on gender identity, sexual orientation and ethnicity, such as the Trump administration’s narrowing of Title IX protections for transgender students, seem contradictory to these core Christian tenets. Do Christian nationalists simply misunderstand Christ’s teachings? Or are more complex factors shaping how Christianity is weaponized in American politics? To analyze Christianity’s modern role in U.S. politics, we must examine the roots of today’s white Christian nationalism.

After the passage of the 13th Amendment in 1865, Black Christians formed their own churches, no longer worshiping alongside their former enslavers. White churches throughout the American South, however, became organizational hubs for hate groups. 

It is essential to acknowledge that the Constitution, despite its references to Christianity, was constructed in order to maintain the institution of slavery, which relied on the dehumanization of Black people. Each of America’s Founding Fathers were complicit in slavery, and most foresaw no end to the system. But the Christian nationalism to which the Constitution alluded to wasn’t just used to defend white supremacy — it actively created and reinforced it. From justifications for seizing indigenous land to the enslavement of Black people, Christianity didn’t just support American white supremacy; it was used to help shape it.

In this way, American Christianity and white supremacy are not simply connected — they have grown together as the country’s foundation. Simply put, racism is not misguided or accidental in this particular brand of American Christianity, but a part of its very definition.

During and after Reconstruction, white churches were complicit in or supported the Jim Crow system. Many opposed civil rights for Black Americans, and the Klu Klux Klan maintained ties to white churches. Additionally, lynchings of Black Americans, often infused with religious symbolism, were framed as protecting “Christian civilization,” despite lacking doctrinal basis.

The Moral Majority, formed in 1979, mobilized Christian conservatives against abortion, feminism, affirmative action, racial integration and LGBTQ+ rights. President Ronald Reagan aligned with this movement, setting a precedent for increased GOP reliance on Christian nationalist rhetoric. From this point, Christian nationalist rhetoric increasingly framed America as divinely ordained and under threat from progressive agendas.

In the 21st century, Christian nationalism continues to grow in American politics. Far-right Christian populism helped Trump to a second term, enabling him to appoint ultra-conservative Christians to key roles. Policies such as Trump’s attempted transgender military ban and restrictions on BIPOC and queer history in schools have been implemented with Christian nationalist support.

These policies seek to restore America’s racial hierarchy and supremacy of heterosexual and male populations, with Christian rhetoric serving as a legitimizing tool. Consequently, lobbing gospel verses at Christian nationalist conservatives in order to highlight hypocrisy, whether online or in public or legislative settings, is not a solution to the co-opting of the Christian faith to uphold America’s foundational white supremacy. 

This type of “gotcha liberalism” — a liberal practice of seeking to fight conservative oppression through outwitting its proponents or disproving its logic, is ultimately futile and diverts attention and needed action from this hypocrisy’s underlying causes. 

While this approach may offer momentary satisfaction or garner viral media attention, it consistently fails to lead to meaningful change. This is because it rests on the assumption that Christian nationalists are operating in good faith, and can be swayed by logical argument, an assumption that breaks down when confronted with an ideology as deeply rooted and historically entrenched as white supremacy. Besides this, the snark and malice often tied to this practice can make it unwelcoming for those who recognize the limitations of their beliefs and are seeking to learn and grow. 

Instead, broad efforts from schools, universities, public media and religious institutions are needed to confront the historical amnesia surrounding white Christian nationalism and educate the public on its enduring role in American politics. Liberal politicians must work to build and strengthen coalitions and networks, amplifying public support via grassroots media free from conservative control and focusing on support of local communities through both legislative and  direct action. 

This oppression must be fought through direct action and resistance, which requires a comprehensive understanding of its causes and catalysts. Politicians and community members must work together to organize boycotts, establish mutual aid networks for food, healthcare and legal support, support labor strikes, and provide legal aid to individuals affected by oppressive policies. These actions directly challenge systems that uphold racial, religious and economic inequality throughout the country. 

“Gotcha liberalism” fails us all, and it is time to do away with it.

One Reply to “‘Gotcha Liberalism’ Fails: Why Christian Nationalists Don’t Care About Your Bible Verses”

  1. Well written and timely. I agree- action, versus mere verbal challenge, is what is required to confront racism in all its forms.

Comments are closed.

css.php