Path Dependence: How Echoes of the Past Affect Our Public Transit

By Adam Noel ’27

Adam Noel ’27

The Eisenhower Institute’s “Building America: Transportation & Health Program” covers a wide variety of topics involving America’s public transit system. The program highlighted that one often overlooked concept in public transit policy is called path dependence, wherein contemporary systems are influenced by often defunct and irrelevant past systems.

Take the Erie Canal, for example. Constructed in the early 1800s, the Erie Canal provided a cheap, efficient route for transporting goods from the Midwest and Great Lakes to the large population center and port in New York City, and vice versa. Though still passable by small watercraft, the Erie Canal’s commercial relevance has greatly waned due to competition from railroads, highways, and larger shipping networks. Yet the immense wealth the Erie Canal brought to its route by its prominence early in its history caused cities along its path to grow in population and relevance, an effect that remains today.  

The Erie Canal’s historical dominance allowed the cities of Buffalo, Rochester, Syracuse, and Utica to gain prominence. Consequently, while there is no longer much economic necessity anymore to have a belt of cities stretching across New York State from Buffalo to Albany, the belt remains, chiefly because of the legacy of the Erie Canal. 

More than that, the fated economic significance of these cities creates a transportation need to link them together. It is no coincidence that the Interstate 90 highway follows almost the same exact route as the Erie Canal, conveniently connecting the cities nurtured by its freight predecessor. The route chosen for I-90 cemented the canal’s legacy by reinforcing its path with modern roads.  

Path dependence is a natural process that hinders innovation but nevertheless eases gentle adaptations by providing a framework or precedent on which to build. After all, with regards to the Erie Canal example, a perfectly straight road between Albany and Erie would be the most efficient path to the interior of the country, but the benefits of allowing the highway to meet the major population and commercial centers along its intended path far outweigh any time or expense sacrifices.  

The principle of path dependence has implications for transportation planning nationwide. Cities and states grappling with questions of rail revitalization, highway expansion, or transit development would do well to examine their own histories. Path dependence is not destiny, but it offers wisdom, highlighting where investments have succeeded and where infrastructure has proven effective. The challenge lies in knowing when, as poet Robert Frost decided, to choose the road less traveled by. 

css.php